Lara Jean and Peter's New Agreement
P.S. I Still Love YouLara Jean and Peter's New Agreement is a handwritten set of promises that gives practical shape to Lara Jean and Peter Kavinsky’s effort to make their relationship work. What begins as Peter’s playful suggestion becomes a negotiated account of what each expects and what neither wants to risk: routine disagreements can be managed, but honesty and care for one another must remain central.
From Suggestion to Written Agreement
The agreement takes shape during a meal, after Peter admits that the situation between them feels a little strange. He proposes a new contract, at first imagining reciprocal routines: nightly calls, attendance at his lacrosse games and some practices, dinners at Lara Jean’s house, and her company at parties. The list is deliberately casual, and Lara Jean cannot tell whether he is joking. She joins in rather than dismissing the idea.
The suggestion strikes her as more useful than its light tone first implies. She considers whether a contract could help them address problems before they grow and hold them both accountable; she even thinks Margot would be proud of the idea. Lara Jean takes a small notebook and pen from her purse and writes Lara Jean and Peter’s New Contract at the top of the page. Putting the proposal on paper changes the exchange: their playful imagining becomes a concrete act of negotiation.
The first clause she writes says Peter will be on time. Peter leans over to read it upside down and objects to the wording, giving their drafting process the same teasing, argumentative quality as their conversation. Later, Peter groans loudly at another point of disagreement, and Lara Jean reaches across the table, takes him by the collar, and kisses him. The kiss interrupts their quarrel, but the narrator distinguishes this bickering from arguments that hurt their feelings: this kind of friction makes them feel like themselves again.
Terms and Negotiation
The final terms adjust the initial proposal rather than simply accepting it. Peter may not be more than five minutes late, turning Lara Jean’s opening demand into a specific allowance. Lara Jean, in turn, promises not to make Peter do crafts. The two clauses make room for their recognizable differences while setting limits on the irritations each is willing to tolerate.
The imagined nightly call also becomes less prescriptive. Peter does not have to call Lara Jean before bed, though he may do so if he wants. Parties are handled from Lara Jean’s side: she will go only when she feels like it. In contrast, Peter promises to give her rides whenever she wants. Together, these arrangements distinguish invitations and gestures of care from obligations. The contract is not a schedule requiring equal participation in every activity; its settled terms leave each person some choice while making support available.
Honesty, Friendship, and Heartbreak
The agreement’s central safeguard is a promise that Lara Jean and Peter will always tell each other the truth. Its importance is underscored by a separate, carefully qualified term about Genevieve. Peter may remain friends with her, provided he is open with Lara Jean about that friendship. The clause does not demand that Peter end the connection; it makes candor the condition for continuing it. In this way, the written agreement addresses a sensitive relationship not by forbidding it, but by specifying what Lara Jean needs from Peter.
Lara Jean also wants the contract to protect them from a larger danger than lateness or unwanted crafts. She hesitates to raise the subject while things are going smoothly, then tells Peter that she does not want them ever to break each other’s hearts. Peter responds by proposing that they put the idea into the contract. Lara Jean writes their promise not to break each other’s hearts into the notebook, visibly relieved. The exchange turns a fear neither can control completely into a promise they can make together; the scene acknowledges that heartbreak is not necessarily planned, even as they commit themselves to avoiding it.
Meaning of the Agreement
The agreement’s form matters as much as its individual rules. It begins in joking conversation, acquires a title and clauses in Lara Jean’s notebook, and ends with a mutual promise. Its terms are neither a rigid set of commands nor a guarantee that the relationship will never encounter difficulty. They are negotiated commitments, revised as each person responds to the other, with room for choice alongside obligations to be truthful and considerate.
The sequence also links ordinary relationship maintenance to emotional vulnerability. Punctuality, calls, parties, rides, and crafts give the pair concrete matters to bargain over; Genevieve’s friendship brings transparency into the bargain; the final promise names the deeper stake beneath it all. The kiss and their return to familiar bickering mark a shift from strained disagreement toward ease, while the written clauses give that ease a practical framework. The agreement’s decisive gesture is not that it prevents every future hurt, but that Lara Jean and Peter make their expectations explicit and record their intention to face the relationship honestly together.

